Straight against swung & Harmonic Variations
Lesson time: (5min 46sec)
Course preview
This lesson is part of the course Play Authentic New Orleans Piano
Watch a preview of the full course below.
Lesson transcript:
Music Lesson: Exploring Rhythmic Feel and Harmony
There's tunes, you know, it's often played with that kind of straight kind of feel. But you can throw in, kind of, you know, play a swung feel against the straight, which I find can be really fun as well.
Swung vs. Straight Feel
- Straight Feel: Start off playing a straight rhythm.
- Swung Feel: Then you heard me go into the more swung, shuffly feel in the middle of that before coming back into the straight feel.
This can be really effective, which I sometimes do in this tune, particularly when I'm using tenths in the left hand.
Using Tenths
And that's another thing you can do. So, something like this:
Throwing around a few more tenths in that version.
Maybe looking back to more of that kind of stride-influenced idea that we looked at in "Somebody Changed the Lock."
Chord Movements
This kind of thing is a really nice movement towards that V chord, which is essentially a V7, but with the fifth in the bass. You will have also noticed a few little chord substitutions in there. Rather than doing the standard one for a bar, then five to a bar, actually going around the houses, going around a sort of 1 6 2 5 turnaround, which works really nicely.
And again, this can set up that slightly more Cuban feel. You could put a cheeky little 2:5 in before going to chord four.
Understanding the 2:5 Transition
By 2:5, I mean in the key going to the chord of B flat:
- II V would be a C.
- That's an F.
So, preceding the F7, which you'd normally play in the sequence with a C minor.
Example Progression
- Something like this, then maybe a cheeky little E flat 7 there leading back to the F.
- Or you could play the second bar of the B flat as a B flat minor.
Changing the harmony up very quickly.
Incidentally, on that 2:5 going to the B flat, you could play the voicing like that, which is a very kind of Dr. John thing to do.
Then maybe play the B flat as A major seven. There you go.
Final Thoughts
I think we've looked at quite a lot of aspects on this tipertina. I mean, you can take it anywhere. You could extend those harmonies in all kinds of more jazz directions.
- Maybe look at some other feels.
- Indeed, Booker kind of plays it as a shuffle in one of his versions.
I'd love to hear what you do with the tune, so feel free to upload a copy and send a link over. It'd be great to see.
Cool. Let's look at something else.
About the instructor

Paddy Milner is recognised as one of the leading blues piano players in the world - he is currently keyboard player of choice for Sir Tom Jones, following several years with the late, great Jack Bruce - but he is also a superb original songwriter and a distinctive singer. Just read the praise from the likes of Dave Brubeck below! His playing was featured on the soundtrack for the hit 2019 film 'Rocketman'. He has twice won the award for Best Keyboard Player in the British Blues Awards, and he holds a long-standing residency as a founder member of the Ronnie Scott's Blues Explosion at the world-renowned Ronnie Scott's club. His current group LONDONOLA plays homegrown British music with a strong dose of New Orleans spirit, and his collaborative group JAWBONE goes from strength to strength following the release of their self-titled debut album. "I love it... there's a guy who can really play the piano" - Dave Brubeck "I highly recommend it. Somehow things start to feel much better!" - Jack Bruce "The best blues piano player in Europe..." - Blues Access, USA "Impressive & original" - The Times "Dazzling" - The Independent Across his courses, Paddy breaks down authentic blues shuffle, slow blues, boogie-woogie, rock 'n' roll and New Orleans piano - right down to three classic boogie-woogie songs - so you can learn these styles from one of the very best in the business. read more




